Enjoy some of the best waterfront views on Delmarva while experiencing fresh Atlantic cuisine at Catch 54 by widely acclaimed chef Matt Haley.
Our newly built, two-story restaurant highlights the picturesque setting of Fenwick Island while providing a taste of coastal Delaware in a lively, casual atmosphere. Dine on locally caught seafood, steaks and more or enjoy a cocktail or bottle of wine at our expansive main or marina bars.
Catch 54 is located in Fenwick Island on Route 54, with both indoor and outdoor dining overlooking the waters of the Cove.
Our pleasant, personable staff will ensure that you and your family enjoy your meal from start to finish. Come see why diners across the region eagerly look forward to their visits to Catch 54.
We're sorry, but we do not accept reservations.
Recent Reviews
Catch 54
Martin Vanta : 5 on 7/13/2026 11:16 pm
My first visit here and easily one of the most memorable dining experiences I’ve had in the area. Catch 54 came highly recommended by friends who live locally, and it absolutely lived up to the expectations.
The location alone is special, but what really stood out was the atmosphere — professional service without ever feeling stiff or overly formal. The staff was friendly, relaxed, and genuinely welcoming from the moment we arrived. We asked for an outdoor table and happily waited a few minutes for one, which was more than worth it.
Dinner outside with the sunset over the water felt almost magical. The oysters, mussels, shrimp, cocktails, and Italian wine were all excellent, and the quality easily matched the setting. Considering the experience, the pricing felt very reasonable as well.
A place I’ll gladly return to whenever I’m back in the area, and one I’d recommend without hesitation.
The location alone is special, but what really stood out was the atmosphere — professional service without ever feeling stiff or overly formal. The staff was friendly, relaxed, and genuinely welcoming from the moment we arrived. We asked for an outdoor table and happily waited a few minutes for one, which was more than worth it.
Dinner outside with the sunset over the water felt almost magical. The oysters, mussels, shrimp, cocktails, and Italian wine were all excellent, and the quality easily matched the setting. Considering the experience, the pricing felt very reasonable as well.
A place I’ll gladly return to whenever I’m back in the area, and one I’d recommend without hesitation.
Martin Vanta
1783984594
5
5
Catch 54
Jen Garone : 5 on 5/28/2026 2:09 am
Clean, new with a great view. Across the board, the staff is friendly. The prices are good, especially for a resort town. My shrimp and grits were delicious. The salmon was cooked perfectly. The beets accompanying the salmon was an interesting choice, not one I’d make. Ice cream is yummy.
Jen Garone
1779934144
5
5
Catch 54
Ricardo A. : 5 on 4/1/2026 12:12 pm
Waterfront dining experience!! Gorgeous views from the inside and outside. This place looked amazing inside as well. Walls done in a elegant white, with wood beams throughout the first and second floor. Oysters were to die for!! 😋 food was spectacular! Only issue is parking but up the block there is a parking lot. Its a dead end so if you notice parking early up the street I would take it instead of performing k-turns at the dead end 😉. Will definitely return to this amazing place!! The martini was also a favorite 😍 of mine. Enjoy!!
Ricardo A.
1775045554
5
5
Catch 54
Modal title