Delmar Pizza

Having lived here my whole life, I want to like Delmar Pizza, but I just can't stomach to do it any more. 25 years ago it was actually good, and I've just watched the food quality go downhill year after year. They buy the cheapest of the cheapest quality ingredients and nothing is seasoned at all. Bland, flavorless, poor quality food. I think people who give a good review either a) do so out of nostalgia, or b) if you put enough melted greasy cheese on top of something you can eat anything. Their pizza went from eh, mediocre to just awful . The cheap dollar store bread like crust has no flavor, the sauce is watered down and flavorless, and it gets worse as it cools down. The grilled chicken is sketchy and unseasoned, the chicken steak is the cheapest quality frozen sheets you can buy. At least they used to use Liscio's rolls, but the last 2 times they had some horrible soft roll. Even their fries which used to be good now aren't cooked properly (too low a temp and soak up stale grease flavor), but they sprinkle a bit of reddish powder on them but zero salt. I thought maybe the problem was takeout, but when eating in it was just as bad. They've been refilling the same nasty ketchup bottles for who knows how long (how cheap can you be), and the waitress gave me a hard time about me wanting to BUY ketchup packets (i didn't expect them for free). If you want to buy ketchup in bulk, buy squeeze bottles that are meant to be refilled and sanitized them between filling before you make someone sick! Very skimpy on the salad dressing and cheap produce used both on salad and the sub toppings. As far as dining in, they now have super cheap looking furniture that is rock hard and not even comfortable sitting, guess they trying to get people in and out as fast as possible! There was not one redeeming thing about my last in-person visit, nor my last takeout visit. No more, I've been done, but am really just done. Why be in business if you don't care about making quality food?

It has been 30 years since I last ate at Delmar Pizza. My husband and I returned to Delaware for a visit and we're looking forward to the nostalgia of our younger years. We were not disappointed the food was just as we remembered, if not better! Thank you for the wonderful service and the delicious food!

I drove up there from Salisbury to get an extra large Pizza for my husband and me, because it has been rated the Best of the Eastern Shore for many years. It did not disappoint! Got a Quad Pizza and all 4 toppings were very fresh, going right out to the edge of the delicious crust..
unlike a popular pizzeria in Salisbury where the toppings were scant, maybe on only half the diameter of the Pizza. The crust was delicious, not too thick and not too thin. The staff was friendly, the restaurant super clean. Well worth the drive!! 😋